I have not seen the movie The Help nor have I read the best-seller on which it is based. However, I have read quite a few blog posts and online articles offering varying opinions in a racial discourse that questions whether the movie provides any illuminating racial insight or whether it is just another cinematic example of black women being used to bolster white women's stories and lives. First off, this is not a slam against black domestics. My grandmother was a domestic who served a white family for many years. Her sacrifice provided food for her family and even provided me hand-me-downs when my mother and I ultimately came to live with her and my grandfather. I particularly remember a favorite red robe which I wore over the years until it became threadbare. It didn't matter that it was a boy's robe; my grandmother had given it to me with much love and it was so comfortable.
It has been suggested in many discussions that the depiction of the maids in the movie does nothing more than perpetuate the lingering "mammy" trope which has been a troubling stereotype foisted upon black women for years. It had been hoped that this trope had died a natural death with the progression of time but seemingly this is not the case. Unfortunately, the overwrought character is one which mainstream audiences never seem to tire of and therefore refuse to let die. To many who see the character as benign, there is something comforting about a black woman who gives so totally of herself that she has nothing left for herself or her family.
For those who think that this sentiment does not carry over into real life, I'm a living testament to how even distracted benevolence shown by a black women can be mistaken for mammyism. Case in point, while in my early 30s I temped at a well-known financial auditing company. While there I befriended a young, socially naive secretary in her 20s. She had a pleasant attitude and I didn't mind talking with her and on a few occasions going out to lunch. We talked about various things, nothing particularly soul-searching or earth-moving. One of the things she shared with me during our talks was her love of R&B music and old movies. Well one day out of the blue she shyly admitted to me that I reminded her of a character from one of her favorite movies. Can you guess which movie? When she said Gone with the Wind, I immediately knew my options were either Butterfly McQueen's character (can't remember the name) or Mammy. As I was overweight, I also immediately knew which role she would typecast me as.
I must have shown my shock when she uttered the "beloved" name. She truly believed I should have been flattered at the comparison. I let it go, biting my bitterness and shock. Still someone must have later clued her in about the insult because the next day she apologized stating that she didn't know she had mistakenly insulted me. She then bolstered the apology by saying she only thought of me that way because I was so nice and so "bosomy" that she felt like I was comforting. Yeah right. OK. 'Cause that's what I was there for.
Going back to the issue at hand, in cinematic history the mammy role was often interchanged with that of the black maid. Actresses Louise Beaver and Hattie McDaniel (the original Mammy) were often typecast as either and I can't really be mad at them because those were the roles that were mostly offered to African-American actresses during that time. Again, there is nothing wrong with being a maid or portraying one. But why did the producers of that time insist that the character be oversolicitous and all sacrificing? And in some cases racially demeaning? Again, it was a matter of audience entertainment and "comfortability." Many white audiences, for various reasons, wanted to believe that black women were truly as depicted. My former co-worker would have fit well in those audiences.
I'm wary whenever I watch movies from the early 20th century because I know many of them are rife with black stereotypes. However, I recall a couple of movies I saw many years ago where a particular black actress caught my attention. In both movies, the actress portrayed a maid; however, in both cases, the maid was depicted as well-spoken, dignified and dare I say it, attractive. It was as though the producers of those films hadn't received the memo that all black maids were supposed to speak in dialect, be overly solicitous, and treat her employers as though they were her own children. It is only recently that I discovered the name of the actress: Theresa Harris. To learn more about her check out her bio at BlackPast.org. and Wikipedia. I found more information about Ms. Harris from an article written by journalist Sherry Howard. The New York Times also wrote a bio on Harris.
I truly can't recall which movies I saw Ms. Harris in, only that she made a lasting impression on me even these years later. From reading her various bios, it seems that she, like Beaver and McDaniel, was often typecast as a domestic. However, Ms. Harris' elegant and dignified portrayal disproved those many years ago (and disproves even today) any mistaken belief that black maids had to be portrayed for laughs or overly servile so as not to upset the audience's comfort level.
Below is footage of one of Ms. Harris' non-domestic roles in which she sings "Daddy Won't You Please Come Home."
Here she is again (this time in "uniform") in Buck Benny Rides Again.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 9/09/2011 10:23:00 AMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Monday, August 29, 2011
Il Grande Silenzio (The Great Silence), 1968
I found this clip in a Youtube search and although I've never seen the movie, which is a notable spaghetti western by famed director Sergio Corbucci, the silent chemistry between the actors Vonetta McGee and Jean-Louis Trintignant is smoldering. Unfortunately, the lovers have a star-crossed ending according to Wikipedia. Actually their ending is quite brutal as depicted in another clip I discovered (and won't show here) so I don't particularly want to see the whole film.
What I will note is that the storyline is extraordinary in that the Af-Am actor McGee is featured as the wife of a Mormon and then the lover of the protagonist-gunfighter - and this in 1968. Which begs the question whether 21st cinema has truly progressed since this movie. I really don't think so.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 8/29/2011 07:24:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Choose Me
With a novella due out later this month, I'm already contemplating my next project. Although I'm still formulating the plot, I already know that I want to set it in the back streets of L.A. I picture dark streets and alleys with a noir ambiance to them. The primary locus will be a small jazz club with a bevy of odd characters coming and going. Noir can be dark, moody, sexy and no where is that seductively depicted than in the Alan Rudolph's 1984 movie Choose Me starring Keith Carradine, Lesley Ann Warren, Genevieve Bujold and Rae Dawn Chong. The movie also featured a jazz club amid the dark back streets of L.A., where prostitutes, lonely wanderers, the lovelorn, and in one case an escaped mental patient, converge in a series of quirky, love-crossed misadventures. The mood was set by a bluesy soundtrack sung by the late, great Teddy Pendergrass. Below is the original trailer that ran back in 1984 that had me eager to get to the nearest theater.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 1/31/2010 09:31:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Thursday, October 01, 2009
Late eulogies
I'm way late for my eulogies to Patrick Swayze, one of the actors I really liked both on and off screen. So here's a scene from my favorite Swayze film, "To Wong Foo..."
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 10/01/2009 03:03:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Saturday, December 20, 2008
Another view of "It's a Wonderful Life"
I thought I was the only one who just didn't buy into the happy, ever after of the Christmas classic It's a Wonderful Life. The perennial favorite supposedly tells the moral of the wealth of friendship, which is all fine and good. However, there were elements of the tale that just nagged at me, and it seems Wendell Jamieson of the New York Times agrees with me. Here's a perspective that people seem to overlook when watching the movie's warm and fuzzy coda where all of George Bailey's family and friends gather around him after bailing him out of his financial difficulties: this is a man who has sacrificed himself totally, including his dreams and desires to get out of Bedford Falls, become a world-class architect and travel the world. And how, in the end, can that be a good thing? To subsume one's self so totally is in effect a nightmare. As Jamieson puts it:
"It's a Wonderful Life" is a terrifying, asphyxiating story about growing up and relinquishing your dreams, of seeing your father driven to the grave before his time, of living among bitter, small-minded people. It is a story of being trapped, of compromising, of watching others move ahead and away, of becoming so filled with rage that you verbally abuse your children, their teacher and your oppressively perfect wife. It is also a nightmare account of an endless home renovation.
Jamieson also smashes the illusion of one person being so pivotal to so many lives that those lives would be upended if that man were never born.
Now as for that famous alternate-reality sequence: This is supposedly what the town would turn out to be if not for George. I interpret it instead as showing the true characters of these individuals, their venal internal selves stripped bare. The flirty Violet (played by a supersexy Gloria Grahame, who would soon become a timeless film noir femme fatale) is a dime dancer and maybe a prostitute; Ernie the cabbie’s blank face speaks true misery as George enters his taxi; Bert the cop is a trigger-happy madman, violating every rule in the patrol guide when he opens fire on the fleeing, yet unarmed, George, forcing revelers to cower on the pavement.
I agree that if one person is the only barrier between you and madness or criminality or a life of banality, then there is something inherently wrong with you whether that person is in your life or not. Because if that person were to die or leave, you'd be f*cked.
Jamieson also notes as did Salon writer Gary Kamiya in 2001 that Pottersville just seems a more fun, livelier place to be than the stultifying, Rockwellian Bedford Falls.
Now I'm sure there are many who would disagree with this more dystopian perspective, but it's just another view, one that questions the oft held belief that friends and family are all you need. Sometimes folks, you do need a bit more - like self-actualization.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 12/20/2008 09:03:00 AMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Vampires - the new bad boys in town
Sarah Haskins of Current.com has an entertaining and often bitingly droll way of breaking down the idiocies aimed at women and girls. This time around, she tries to determine just what women (or girls, in this case) see in the brooding, stalkerish Edward Cullen of Twilight infamy. Is it the bad boy allure or his eternal devotion that has millions of readers ready to offer their necks...and much, much more? Note, I have not seen the movie nor read any of the series by Stephenie Meyer, but I'm always curious as to why a mania arises. Right now, everything is vampires, whether it's Twilight for the younger set or Trueblood for those of us in the over-the-hill demographic. And yes, I admit to enjoying Trueblood, although none of the vamps really do it for me. I like the much alive Sam and the over-the-top Lafayette (although not as a love interest; we'd fight over the nail polish).
Unfortunately, the "bad boy" image (this time vis a vis an eternally young, eternally beautiful vampire who seems very controlling) is romanticized in books and movies, brainwashing young women and girls into believing that excitement is only offered through unhealthy relationships. So, is it surprising then that we witness the fallout of these relationships on shows like Maury Povich or Tyra Banks?
To be honest, I always thought Robert Pattinson was kind of cute ever since his turn as Cedric Diggory in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. But if I ever encountered a dead man walking, no matter how attractive, you can bet you would see a live woman running...and screaming. I ain't no fool.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 12/10/2008 09:29:00 AMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Sunday, November 02, 2008
Des boys are miscegenated...
For some reason, this scene from O Brother Where Art Thou (the only Cooney film I really like, BTW) reminds me of the current election with all its racial animus and spurious allegations.... "That negra sold his soul to the devil!" The funny part is that the race-baiting candidate finds himself perplexed that his allegations don't get the response he anticipated ("Is you is, or is you ain't my constituency?"). Actually, his race baiting flies right back to slap him in the face...in this case in the form of thrown tomatoes.
PS: Never thought I would like bluegrass, but that tune "Constant Sorrow" is kinda catchy.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 11/02/2008 10:50:00 AMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Monday, September 22, 2008
The real story behind Lakeview Terrace
Here's the true case the movie is based on. Writer Carl Koslowski deems the movie a "cop-out" as the movie's producers fail to acknowledge the connection between the movie and the pain of the actual plaintiffs in this case. Ironically, I've read at least one comment that stated that the movie isn't plausible because the actions of the cop-neighbor are so extreme. They should read the actual account.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 9/22/2008 03:30:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
70s Movies of the Week
Years ago, long before the proliferation of reality television and nite-time game shows (most of which are cheap productions by way of money and creativity), network producers knew they had to spend some change to entertain their nightly audiences. Whereas today's network producers compete to come up with even more outrageous (and again, cheap) reality TV fare, 70s network television fed its audiences a regular menu of movies of the week, some of which I remember as being entertaining, if somewhat hackneyed. Outside of the occasional CBS Hallmark production, most of which runs from sentimental to chokingly maudlin, network TV barely offers movies anymore.
I grew up in the 70s and remember looking forward to movies of the week, most of which tended to try to scare or at least unnerve their audiences. Some offered basic horror tropes while others tried for the occasional apocalyptic scare. Compared to today's movie productions, these mostly B and C movies were schlocky, melodramatic, even sometimes groan-inducing. No matter; I ate them up like sugary pablum and in my reminisce, I actually miss the attempt at creativity that is so woefully missing today.
Some of you might remember these titles: Where Have All the People Gone or The Day the Earth Moved. Neither of these were in danger of ever winning an Oscar; what they gained, however, were a cult following if for nothing more than their over-the-top drama, cheesy production values, and sometimes convoluted premises - all of which made for some good B-movie watching. It seemed that each week, a movie was telling us that the earth was due to betray us for our shortsightedness. Because of our maltreatment, we should expect some biological anomaly or some nuclear disaster that would pulverize us or cause major destruction.
And if we couldn't be shaken by an earthly catastrophe, there was always satan to unnerve us. Movies like Trilogy of Terror, Satan's Triangle, and Satan's School for Girls offered horror by way of unearthly possessions and satanic ritualisms that promised not only loss of life but soul as well. Many of these movies were obviously trying to ride the popularity of The Exorcist and The Omen, and they rode them bumpily but to good effect sometimes. If you have never seen a woman possessed by a voodoo doll, you need to rent Trilogy if only to see the underrated Karen Black with serrated teeth in a haunched pose, holding a hunting knife, waiting for dear ole miserable mom to come through the door.
Then there was the odd loner trope, the malevolent misfit who wasn't only misunderstood but murderous, as well. The primary rep of this trope was Bad Ronald, the adolescent loony hiding behind the wall peeking in on the new family taking up residence in his former home. Unfortunately, the family has three daughters who provide fodder for Ronald's delusional world. Ever wonder what that is going bump in the night? Just knock on the walls; if there's an answering knock and a light from a peephole, run as fast as possible.
There was no subject that wasn't used in one of these movies; alien impregnation (The Stranger Within); the Bermuda Triangle (entitled simply The Bermuda Triangle); mutated animals and insects (Night of the Lepus) - you can't imagine how carnivorous rabbits can get when they tower over you. Screw carrots and turnips.
If you didn't know, director Steven Spielberg got his start with television movies. Before road rage even had a name, Spielberg featured Dennis Weaver encountering a faceless truck driver seeking to run him down for the impertinence of passing him. Trying to outrun a looming truck can get kind of dicey and Spielberg knew how effective symbolism was even then. Whether a big wheeler or a shark fin, mix it with some effective music, and you have stomach-twisting tension and drama.
Other recommendations, many of which are on DVDs: Don't Be Afraid of the Dark, The House that Wouldn't Die, Haunts of the Very Rich, The Screaming Woman, Five Desperate Women, and Something Evil.
Yeah, some of these movies may seem cheesy compared to the high production values of today's movies. But they attempted to do what many of today's movies do not; find humor (and yes, there is humor in a movie about murderous rabbits) as well as horror thru honest emotions and not just with FX gimmicks and hi-tech stunts.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 7/22/2008 08:45:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Friday, May 18, 2007
Good or Bad Hair
When Imus spouted off about Jigaboos vs. Wannabees in his infamous diatribe last month, he was most likely referencing this fantasy scene from Spike Lee's movie, School Daze (one wonders whether the man actually watched the film). This song-and-dance scene served as a metaphor of the tension between two groups of women attending a fictional black college - one group light-skinned with straightened or weaved hair and the other group dark-skinned with natural styles. Instead of appreciating the beauty in the other, the women allowed their differences to divide them, succumbing to the venal colorism that arose out of slavery days.
Although the movie received mixed reviews, one can appreciate Lee's putting the truth out there. Many castigated him for airing our "dirty laundry" as though no one knew before the movie that blacks straightened their hair or wore weaves or that some wished they were lighter skinned. And if you think this situation has improved in the twenty years since the movie was released, just check some of the comments for the video. There's some pain still going on there, as shown by the comment of one woman recounting trying to straighten her hair and lighten her skin with bleach to fit in with her lighter tormenting peers. We're not that far removed in time from the black elite clubs who once offered entrance to those who could pass the "paper bag" test, where the skin color of the applicant had to be lighter than that of a paper bag before they were allowed into the club. Which only goes to prove that a hierarchical society will always find something by which to define and divide, even to its detriment.
Update: Unfortunately, a woman can be intelligent and accomplished, but obviously she's not worth more than her hair as Chicago Sun-Times columnist Mary Mitchell recently found out. Read I'll Keep My Nappy Hair, Thank You.
Sharon Cullars Coffee Talk at 5/18/2007 07:09:00 PMPermanent Link  
|
|
Home
---------------oOo---------------
Saturday, May 12, 2007
Revisiting 28 Days Later
In anticipation of the new release 28 Months Later, Amanda at Pandagon takes a critical look at its 2005 horror-thriller prequel, 28 Days Later. Noting the movie's obvious symbolism of the viral nature of violence as represented by the man-made Rage, Amanda expands on its other underlying message of patriarchal misogyny that is represented by the movie's supposed saviors, a band of soldiers who actually turn out to be a greater menace than the rampaging zombies.
A sleeper when first released, 28 Days quickly became a critical and popular success with its reworking of the zombie mythology in modern-day London, despite not having (or maybe because of not having) a major American star at the helm. Unlike the zombies - well, actually ghouls - from Romero's Dead series, who are reanimated through radiation, the zombies in 28 Days are the victims of a bioengineered virus that is released into the populace through the stupid actions of a few zealous animal activists attempting to save some infected chimpanzees. The unwitting activists don't know that within seconds, the virus can turn sane human beings into mindless, raging creatures bent on killing and passing on the virus (thus the name Rage). Of course, the activists are the first victims and quickly spread the disease to those around them. Within 28 days, all of London and most of the world, actually, are ghost towns full of dead bodies and hungry zombies.
The hero, Jim, awakes in a hospital room to the devastation, having been in a coma when the infection first hit. He wanders out of the hospital, alone and confused and is almost killed by a band of zombies, saved in the nick of time by a couple of survivors that include a young woman named Selena. Selena is a no-prisoner-taking, machete-wielding sister who kills in the blink of an eye, which her former companion unfortunately finds out when he becomes infected. Eventually Jim and Selena happen upon another survivor and his teenage daughter, and all four set out to find out how many humans are left. Unfortunately for them, they think they have found salvation when they catch a taped broadcast on their radio purporting to be from an outpost of military survivors claiming to have the cure for the virus. They set off cross country to find the outpost and the "cure."
This is where the movie breaks with the traditional monster myth as the audience, and eventually the protagonists, soon come to realize that although the zombies pose an obvious danger, there is a more immediate threat when man de-evolves into a lawless breed intent upon their own satisfaction at the expense of other's right to freedom and life. In this case, the soldiers decide they want to keep the women as forced concubines, and when Jim protests and tries to help the women escape the makeshift barricade, all hell breaks out.
For those of you who haven't seen the movie, I'm not going to divulge the story further than this, only to say that ironically in the end, it is one lone zombie who is the salvation for the survivors.
Amanda does a better job of breaking down the symbolism: "The virus that's infecting the population and turning them into zombies, however, is a manifestation of the boiling rage that spreads across the planet through routine violence, though, and as the military is ground zero in training people to be dehumanizing killing machines, it turns out the survivors are not as safe inside a military barricade as they'd like to think. This is when Boyle [the director] does something I actually didn't expect and positions male dominance and violence towards women - inspired very literally by womb envy - as the ground zero point in creating senseless violence that will spin out of control. The soliders(sic) in the barricade are understandably excited to have young women in their midst, since a bunch of dudes can hardly rebuild civilization all by their lonesome. But rather than be happy and gracious towards the women, they instead reveal to Jim that they're going to hold them captive and subject them to gang rape. The movie firmly rules against the idea that men are inherently thuggish and controlling towards women, since Jim and another male character don't even have a moment's thought towards harming any women just because they can get away with it. Instead, the macho culture of the military is held to account, having made these men so stupid and violent that they don't even pause to consider that their plans of violence towards the women will only have the effect of poisoning their miniature society from the get-go."
That last sentence is exactly what ran through my mind when I first watched the movie. I kept thinking, don't these assholes know they're endangering themselves by hurting those who could have their backs in a battle? I may be naive, but it just seemed stupid in the face of danger to alienate allies. I thought that in a real situation of danger, where it would be us-vs-them, soldiers would behave accordingly, pondering the risks of turning on fellow allies and creating enemies within the camp. But then came news reports on female soldiers suffering PTSD from having been raped by fellow soldiers in Iraq. I realized then just how naive I had been.
To really get insightful perspectives on the movie, read the comments to Amanda's post. There are also some perceptive comparisons to George Romero's Dead series as well as the apocalyptic Children of Men.